Heat treatable low emissivity coatings for architectural glass application

Date: 6 August 2014
  • Leybold Optics GmbH, Alzenau, Germany
Heat treatable low emissivity coatings for architectural glass application
Photo source
This paper describes an alternative set of layers stacks which comprises only metallic and oxidic layers and which can be obtained with Leybold Optics’ coaters.

Udo Schreiber 1, Ingo Wegener 1, Sven Stille 1, Dr. Jutta Trube 1, Dr. Stephan Küper 1

1 Leybold Optics GmbH, Alzenau, Germany



Large area coating, heat treatable low emissivity coating, heat isolation, safety glass manufacturing



Heat treatable low emissivity layer stacks available in the market are often proprietary and involve all of metallic, oxidic and nitridic layers. This paper describes an alternative set of layers stacks which comprises only metallic and oxidic layers and which can be obtained with Leybold Optics’ coaters.

The stacks consist of a silver layer contained in an appropriate arrangement of different blocking and dielectric layers with a high reflectance in infrared spectra range and high transmittance for visual light. It withstands heat treatment requirements for safety glass production.

The described layer stack provides a transmittance of more than 80% at a sheet resistance of less than 3Ω/□. By splitting the silver into two or three different layers with dielectric films in between it is possible to reduce the sheet resistance to 1 Ω/□ at a transmittance of 76 %. Compared to other temperable layer stacks the solution described here consists of metals and oxides only which contributes to fast and reliable process set up.


1 Introduction

Low emissivity coating (low-e) is a standard application in architectural glass industry to reduce heat exchange of buildings through window glass. It reduces heat loss in winter and heating-up in summer whereby the energy costs for heaters and air conditioning facilities are reduced significantly.

Heat treatable low emissivity coatings are designed for efficient production of thermally toughened safety glass. Due to the fact that tempered glass cannot be cut, a low-e coating that withstands the tempering process for safety glass manufacturing is coated on standardized large area glass panes. As it can be produced with high throughput and high coating yield it is a cost efficient way to provide low-e coatings on tempered architectural glass.


2 Layer stack design


2.1 Single low-e

The basic layer stack design shown in the first figure consists of a high reflective silver layer in combination with several dielectric layers. Those are arranged in an appropriate way to achieve good infrared reflection in combination with high visible transmittance.

In order to protect the silver layer from oxidation during tempering by diffusing oxygen atoms it is important to choose proper working points for the dielectric layers as well as for the blocker ZnO:Al.

[Figure 1] Schematic drawing of basic layer stack


2.2 Further layer stack embodiments

The presented basic layer stack can be modified by splitting the silver into two or three different layers, each of them embedded between AZO as seed layer and ZnO:Al as blocker. Splitting silver into several layers makes the spectrum transition from visual to infrared wavelength range steeper and realizes a lower sheet resistance at high visual transmittance.


3 Optical and electrical properties

3.1 Transmittance

Figure 2 shows typical transmittance spectra for single (SLE), double (DLE) and triple silver low-e (TLE) with its maxima around 550nm and different slopes between visual and infrared wavelength range. Due to splitting the silver layer the ability of blocking NIR light improves significantly.

[Figure 2] Transmittance spectra of different layer stack embodiments


3.2 Reflectance

The reflectance spectra in Figure 3 show a very low reflectance in visible range and a very high reflectance in infrared range, corresponding to the transmittance curves.

[Figure 3] Reflectance spectra

The triple low-e spectrum shows two minima in visual range and a local maximum in between. This behavior makes the adjustment of specified reflectance color values more difficult compared to single and double low-e systems because a small change of one minimum causes a large shift of color values.


3.3 Reflective color impression

Proper dimensioning of the dielectric layers is required in order to tune the reflective color impression to a neutral or slightly bluish (cool) value, which is requested by most customers. Thus the a* and b* values of the Lab color space have to be 0 or slightly negative. The layer stacks presented in this paper allow tuning of the color to the requested impression (Figure 4)

[Figure 4: Reflective color impression]

3.4 Sheet resistance

The emissivity of a low-e layer stack depends on the sheet resistance according to [1]:

ε = 0.0129 x R□ - 6.7 x 10-5 x R□²

Splitting the silver layer has a positive influence on the ratio between visual transmittance and sheet resistance, so that the emissivity is reduced significantly.


4 Influence of tempering process

Safety glass is produced by temperature induced change of glass structure. Applying a necessary temperature of 650°C for 10 min strains the coating so extremely that physical properties of the layer stack change and the silver layer may be damaged.

The root cause of these problems is diffusion of sodium out of the glass and oxygen that reacts with the silver layer. These damages are prevented by applying dense diffusion barriers as first and last layers and using blockers around the silver which react with oxygen and thereby prevent oxidation of the silver.

Sheet resistance decreases due to heat induced restructuring of the silver. An increasing resistance value indicates oxidation and therefore insufficient silver protection.

Oxidation processes during heat treatment cause shifts in refractive index of dielectrics and reduce absorption of blockers. This leads to increasing transmittance and shifting color values.

The challenge to meet is a compromise between good protection of silver and small changes in transmittance and reflectance color values. This goal is attained by accurate working point adjustments of diffusion barriers and blockers. The presented layer stack benefits from tempering with respect to the resistance properties while maintaining a virtually unchanged color impression.

5 Summary of results

The following experimental  results are obtained with different embodiments of the mentioned layer stack:

[Table 1] Properties of low-e layer stacks

6 Conclusion

In conclusion, the  layer stacks presented in this paper meet actual specifications for low emissivity coatings for insulating architectural glass. A very small shift of color values during tempering process qualifies these coatings for safety glass applications as well. The overall optical and thermal performance is competitive to other state of the art low emissivity products available on the market.

The glass coating customer profits from this stack because of the nitrogen-free process, which provides a more simple process and releases strains on gas separation, thus allowing a more simple coater, which in turn saves on the investment. Lastly, the layer stack is not covered by foreign IP and can be obtained from the coater manufacturer.



[1] Szczyrbowski J., Bräuer G., Ruske M., Schilling H., Zmelty A. (1999): New low emissivity coating based on TwinMag® sputtered TiO2 and Si3N4 layers. – In: Thin Solid Films, Volume 351, Pages 254-259

600450 Heat treatable low emissivity coatings for architectural glass application glassonweb.com
Date: 6 August 2014
  • Leybold Optics GmbH, Alzenau, Germany

See more articles about

See more from this topic

Others also read

Laminated safety glass is an excellent choice for building construction—here’s why.
Laminated safety glass with SentryGlas® ionoplast interlayer has played a key role in enabling the design of an 100-foot-tall glass fin lobby wall on the 150 North Riverside Plaza office building in Chicago, Illinois, USA.
Stiff PVB is suitable for a much wider range of applications than more traditional PVB interlayers.
Multiple glass options offer customized ways to suit different building needs.
Laminated safety glass with SentryGlas® ionoplast interlayer has played a key role in enabling the design of a twisting, all-glass double skin façade on The Shanghai Tower in China — the world’s second tallest building after the Burj Khalifa in Dubai.
In August 2013, the LiSEC development team started a major project with the mission: redesign of the tempering furnaces in order to save manufacturing costs and at the same time increase the process reliability. Result: the AEROFLAT.


Is Kuleleri, Kule: 2, Kat: 22, 4. Levent
34330 Levent-Istanbul/


PPG Industries, Inc.
Leybold Optics GmbH
ACM Mirror Inc.

Add new comment