Politics makes strange energy rules for U.S. glass standards

An age-old admonition in politics and life in general holds that people who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones.

That logic, however, apparently has no bearing when those pitching the political brickbats happen to be two of the world's foremost glass manufacturers, who are locked in a multimillion-dollar battle over what boils down to market share.Now, this is complicated business and I won't try to explain the technical part. Suffice it to say that it involves pending changes in the way that the U.S. Department of Energy sets its specs for window, door and skylight makers so that they best serve consumers.

Those that meet the federal standards established for specific parts of the country earn the coveted Energy Star designation from the Energy Department. The star is akin to the old Good Housekeeping magazine seal of approval; i.e., a product doesn't need the star to be marketed, but it makes the buyers of goods like roofing, refrigerators, air conditioners, windows, skylights, etc., feel more warm and fuzzy if it's attached.

Currently, the energy agency has divided the country into three zones -- sort of hot, medium and cold -- and Michigan-based Guardian Industries would like to keep it that way. British-based glass company Pilkington, however, is pushing for a four-zone setup that would let it qualify more of its product line for the star and make it, the company says, more competitive.

A decision is due this week, perhaps as early as Tuesday. But the struggle for the hearts and minds of the Energy Department, which is headed by former Michigan Republican U.S. Sen. Spence Abraham, is going right down to the wire.

For the record, Abraham's Washington spokesman, Joe McMonigle, says his boss is staying out of the debate and has bucked the decision down to assistant energy secretary David Garman.

"Secretary Abraham doesn't want to politicize labels," said McMonigle. Then he pointed out that the Energy Department has received "several letters" from Michigan's Congress members backing Pilkington's four-zone preference, among them Republican U.S. Reps. Vern Ehlers and Candice Miller.

The behind-the-scenes political maneuvering by Pilkington and Guardian has been intense. Each insists that its preferred plan will save or create jobs and help consumers.

Added to the intriguing mix is Grosse Pointe Park native Mark Valente III, who has been lobbying the Energy Department on behalf of Pilkington and against Guardian, which is owned by the Detroit Pistons' head man, Bill Davidson. The crux of Pilkington's argument against three zones is that it "limits competition."

"Three of the four major U.S. glass manufacturers favor the four-zone approach," Valente said. "Only Guardian wants to keep three."

Steve Farrar, director of international business for Guardian, counters that the three-zone setup assures greater peak energy load and pollution savings, simplicity for consumer selections and greater comfort benefits. Farrar even produced a recent letter from the Energy Star manager that says, "The three-zone alternative remains our preferred alternative."

600450 Politics makes strange energy rules for U.S. glass standards glassonweb.com
Date: 30 April 2003
Source: Det News

See more news about:

See more from these topics:

Others also read

The slogan "50 years of Quality and Security" drew more than 900 experts from 19 countries to Rosenheim on 12 - 14 October
Plenary speakers, USGBC announcements, sustainability and sold out events among highlights
Glass and Glazing Federation conference focuses on latest technology and trends Dubai.
The next engineered transparency conference takes place at the 23rd and 24th of October 2018 during glasstec 2018.
During the AAMA 2016 National Fall Conference, Michael Collins, partner and managing director of Building Industry Advisors, LLC, provided an economic overview and outlook of the window and door industry.
During the AAMA 2016 National Fall Conference, the AAMA Sustainability Steering Committee hosted two speakers who stressed the importance of wellness in buildings the industry assists in creating and renovating.

Add new comment